After trying out all five mascaras I really like the formulation. It also dried quite fast, which was nice because no one likes mascara that takes ages to dry. The only part for me (personally) that I didn't like, was the fact that all the brushes were huge. As someone with very short natural lashes I found it a bit harder to apply without smudging it and would have loved a smaller brush to be included. I did however use these mascaras on my sister who happens to be blessed with amazing lashes and it worked very well on her, which is why I would purchase them again.