I own 5 of these lovely lip liners, and my favourite is Satin Mauve. It looks like my lips but better, which is what everyone wants,right? All 5 of the lip liners have become short little stubs, after so much use hehe..,
I rated it a 4 in effectiveness because with certain colours, they sometimes fade faster than others. BUT the pigment on these are amazing!
I would recommend that you use a lip scrub, so the lipliner don't attach on to dry lip skin (>_