I've been using this makeup remover for about 2 weeks now and I can safely say that this is a great product. I've never used a more effective makeup remover that gets rid of waterproof mascara. I found that i didn't need to rub, it just glided off easily and nothing was left behind.
It does leave behind an oiliness on the skin but I use a great cleanser so getting rid of the residue is no problem and I experienced no breakouts thus far. I love that this is a dual makeup remover that works for both skin and eyes and it doesn't sting or burn my eyes as my eye area is rather sensitive.