I don't know about you guys, but I am very skeptical about trying a new eyeliner, when I had already found one that I liked.
I usually use Revlon's liquid liners and have used many different brands as well, but found that most applicators were too stiff, which made application very unpleasant.
I was surprised to find that Yardley's applicator was similar to Revlon's, which was great news for me as it is a little cheaper.
It is long-lasting and doesn't smudge too easily. I'd say it is a great buy!